Skip to content
Barry Newman, Real Estate Broker at eXp Realty
Aerial view across the North Shore suburbs of Chicago toward Lake Michigan

North Shore and Chicago North comparison

Compare Kenilworth, Barrington Area, Lake Forest, Mettawa & Lake Bluff

Five communities within about 25 miles of each other, and no two of them feel alike. This page compares them factually, and where public data cannot be compared it says so instead of filling the gap with numbers.

The honest overview

Five places, one decision.

Kenilworth is a historic 0.6-square-mile lakefront village with one K-8 school and New Trier beyond; the Barrington Area is a cluster of villages whose centerpiece, Barrington Hills, is five-acre horse country; Lake Forest is a college town split sharply by US-41; Mettawa is a rural Lake County village of about 550 residents; and Lake Bluff is a beach town that shares Lake Forest High School with its larger neighbor.

The table below compares housing character, verified home and lot information, dated value data (with its source and window stated), the school-by-address verification approach, shopping and dining areas, medical facilities, and transportation. After the table come three closer looks: Kenilworth versus Barrington Hills, Lake Forest versus Lake Bluff, and Mettawa versus nearby Libertyville and Vernon Hills.

One standing note: the ZIP-level value figures below come from different providers and windows, so they are directional, not a same-source ranking, and Mettawa's sales sample is too small for any median at all. No school, safety, or “best” rankings appear anywhere on this page, because honest local advice does not start with a list.

Side by side

The five communities, compared.

Every fact below is sourced on the matching guide page for that community, with verification dates and links. Value figures are labeled with their source and reporting period.

Comparison of Kenilworth, Barrington Area, Lake Forest, Mettawa, and Lake Bluff across housing, lots, value data, schools, shopping, medical care, and transportation.
Community Housing character Homes and lots (verified) Value snapshot, source and period Schools: verify by address Shopping and dining Medical facilities Transportation
Kenilworth Cook County About 0.6 square miles and roughly 2,500 residents. Nearly all single-family, much of it pre-1940, with a high concentration of architect-designed homes including about 40 George Maher Prairie School houses. No commercial district. Original lots described in local histories around 100 by 175 feet with deep setbacks; larger lakefront, bluff, and ravine parcels east of Sheridan Road. Median about $2.525 million in ZIP 60043 (Redfin, November 2025); 18 sales that month and 48 in the trailing 12 months (Homes.com). Largest sales are lakefront estates. One K-8 school: Joseph Sears (Kenilworth SD 38, 542 Abbotsford Rd), a district covering the village plus parts of Wilmette and Winnetka; high school is New Trier 203. Verify on the district boundary page. Kenilworth Metra District on Green Bay Road; groceries, shopping, and dining across the line in Wilmette (one store in Evanston). Endeavor Health Evanston Hospital about 2 miles away; Endeavor Health Glenbrook Hospital in Glenview. Metra UP-N at 400 Richmond Rd (accessible, about 30 minutes to Ogilvie); Pace Route 213.
Barrington Area Cook, Kane, Lake, and McHenry Counties Five villages plus Tower Lakes: Barrington (walkable downtown), Barrington Hills (large-lot equestrian estates), South Barrington (subdivisions), and Lake and North Barrington. Municipal boundaries and housing are not interchangeable. Barrington Hills zoning minimums: 5 acres (R-1), 3 (R-2), 2 (R-3), 1 (R-4). South Barrington lots from about 30,000 square feet up to 5 acres. Barrington itself mixes older downtown homes and subdivisions. Median about $850,000 in ZIP 60010 (Movoto, December 2025); RealtyTrac's trailing-12-month median for the ZIP was about $728,810. Sources use different windows; treat as directional. Barrington 220 (PK-12) spans about 72 square miles across four counties; assignment is address-based (South Barrington: Rose Elementary, then Prairie or Station Middle, then Barrington High School). Verify on the boundary map. Downtown Barrington Main Street; the Arboretum of South Barrington; Deer Park Town Center nearby. Advocate Good Shepherd Hospital in Barrington. Metra UP-NW at 201 S Spring St, about eight parking lots (roughly 900 spaces) and Pace bus connections.
Lake Forest Lake County College town of about 19,000. Historic bluffs, ravines, downtown, and the college sit east of US-41; postwar and 1990s subdivisions fill the west side. Zoning minimums about 9,375 square feet (R-1), 20,000 (R-2), and 40,000 (R-3). Lots range from deep narrow downtown parcels to multi-acre bluff estates; Conway Farms single-family lots run about 0.39 to 1.5-plus acres. Median about $1.1 million in ZIP 60045 (Redfin, December 2025) with 67 sales that month; about $379 per square foot; 59 days on market. No full-year aggregate is published by Redfin for the ZIP. Lake Forest SD 67 (Cherokee, Everett, Sheridan through grade 4 by address, then Deer Path Middle); Lake Forest High School (D115) serves Lake Forest, Lake Bluff, and Knollwood. Verify on lakeforestschools.org. Market Square downtown (1916) and the Western Avenue dining and services corridor. Northwestern Medicine Lake Forest Hospital in the city; Endeavor Health Glenbrook Hospital in Glenview. Two Metra stations: UP-N at 691 N Western Ave (downtown and east) and MD-N at 911 Telegraph Rd (west).
Mettawa Lake County Rural Lake County village of about 550, incorporated in 1960. Five-acre estates, horse farms, forest preserves, and conservation land; no commercial district. Most residential zoning requires at least 5 acres per home; conservation communities such as Deerpath Farm protect roughly 140 acres of open land. Sample too small for a median: 5 sales in 12 months (Homes.com) and 1 closed sale in the most recent quarter (Relux). Published figures swing by nearly half between months, so none is presented. Patchwork by exact address: Hawthorn 73, Libertyville 70, Rondout 72, or Lincolnshire-Prairie 103 for elementary; high school splits between Stevenson (D125) and Libertyville (D128) with conflicting public sources. Verify with the applicable districts. No commercial district; Libertyville's MainStreet, Vernon Hills' Hawthorn Mall, and Lake Forest are the nearby shopping and dining. Advocate Condell Medical Center in Libertyville; Northwestern Medicine Lake Forest Hospital in Lake Forest. No station in the village; nearest are Lake Forest (MD-N), Libertyville (MD-N), Prairie View (NCS), and Vernon Hills (NCS).
Lake Bluff Lake County Lakefront village of about 6,000. Resort-era cottages and estates east of the tracks; newer subdivisions west. Downtown, station, beach, and library within walking distance. Lots from about 5,200 square feet to over an acre, with estate properties from about 4 to 25-plus acres on the lakefront. Median about $630,000 in ZIP 60044 (Redfin, November 2025); RealtyTrac's trailing-12-month median about $773,084; Redfin's village-level median about $1.1 million (September 2025). Different windows and mixes. Lake Bluff SD 65 K-8 (121 E Sheridan Pl), then Lake Forest High School (D115) shared with Lake Forest and Knollwood. Verify on lb65.org and lakeforestschools.org. Scranton Avenue downtown; Market Square and the Western Avenue corridor in Lake Forest nearby. Northwestern Medicine Lake Forest Hospital (Lake Forest); Advocate Condell (Libertyville). Metra UP-N at 600 N Sheridan Rd with village-managed parking; Pace Route 563 and VanGo connections.

Value figures are ZIP-level unless noted, come from the stated providers and windows, and are not a same-source comparison; Mettawa's sample is too small for any median. Each community's full guide lists sources with verification dates. This is not an appraisal or an adjusted CMA: ask Barry for current MLS-based figures for the specific street you are considering.

Closer looks

Three comparisons buyers actually make.

Kenilworth versus Barrington Hills

Both are deliberately low-density and preservation-minded, but they protect very different things. Kenilworth preserves a walkable 19th-century street grid on 0.6 square miles; Barrington Hills preserves about 29 square miles of farmland and equestrian country through zoning that demands one to five acres per home.

Kenilworth children walk to one K-8 school, the Joseph Sears School, and ride to New Trier for high school; Barrington Hills children are assigned by address within Barrington 220 across a 72-square-mile, four-county district. Kenilworth's commute is a 30-minute Metra UP-N ride from Richmond Road; Barrington's is the UP-NW from downtown Barrington. Errands in Kenilworth are a short walk or drive to Wilmette; in Barrington Hills they are a drive to Barrington, South Barrington, or Palatine.

Neither offers much commercial life of its own, and both are quiet and leafy in their own ways. The practical tradeoff is lifestyle, not quality: a historic village where the school ladder, the train, and the grocery are close at hand, versus a five-acre estate where the land, the horses, and the privacy are the point and almost everything else is a drive.

Lake Forest versus Lake Bluff

These are lakefront sisters that share a school ladder, Lake Bluff District 65's K-8 followed by District 115's Lake Forest High School, the same UP-N rail line, and the same stretch of Lake Michigan shoreline. The differences are scale, character, and range.

Lake Forest is roughly three times Lake Bluff's size, with two Metra lines, a college, Market Square, historic neighborhoods east of US-41, and 1990s subdivisions to the west. Lake Bluff is a compact village where downtown, station, beach, and library sit within walking distance of each other.

Housing and lots overlap but skew: Lake Forest's bluff and ravine estates run larger and grander, while Lake Bluff mixes modest village homes with a smaller set of lakefront estates. Both districts require documented proof of residency to enroll. The tradeoff: Lake Bluff trades range and variety for walkability and a smaller, more casual footprint; Lake Forest offers more shopping, culture, and housing choice at the price of a bigger, busier city.

Mettawa versus nearby alternatives

Mettawa's five-acre zoning and preserved countryside are the whole point, and they come with real tradeoffs: a school patchwork with conflicting high school sources, no Metra station, no commercial district, no library, and a sales sample too small to cite meaningful values.

Libertyville, about 10 minutes west, offers a walkable MainStreet downtown, its own MD-N station, Advocate Condell hospital, and conventional school districts with predictable boundaries. Vernon Hills, to the south, adds Hawthorn Mall and an NCS station, with denser and more conventional housing. Lake Forest, to the east, brings two Metra lines, hospitals, Market Square shopping and dining, and the D67-D115 school ladder.

The tradeoff is direct: buyers who need Mettawa's land, privacy, and riding trails accept car-based errands and a school-verification burden; buyers who want walkability, predictable schools, and rail access will find all three in Libertyville, Vernon Hills, or Lake Forest. This is a fit question, not a quality ranking, and it depends entirely on the exact address and the family's schedule.

Which of these five fits your plan?

Call or send the form and Barry will walk you through the tradeoffs with current listings, recent sales, and honest guidance on the villages worth your time. Selling? He will bring a written pricing analysis to the first meeting.

Your comparison questions, answered

Tell Barry which communities you are weighing and he will come back with the practical differences that matter for your move.

Privacy Policy

Prefer to talk now? Call or text 847.921.1666.